Some say, 'Delegate more!' while others warn, 'Don't micromanage.' The truth is, there's no one-size-fits-all answer because effective leadership is all about adapting to different situations.
Think of leadership styles like tools in a toolbox. Just as you'd use a different tool for fixing a leaky sink than you would for hanging a picture, you need to adjust your leadership approach depending on the environment and your team's needs.
Why do leadership styles matter? Because they affect everything from team morale to productivity. A mismatched style can lead to confusion and demotivation, while the right style can inspire and energize a team.
Effective leaders recognize that their teams are made up of individuals with unique personalities, skills, and needs. To get the best out of their teams, leaders must adapt their styles to suit diverse situations and workplace environments.
Drawing inspiration from the business classic, "Situational Leadership: The Classic Model of Situational Leadership" by Paul Hersey and Ken Blanchard, this article explores how leaders can tailor their approach to meet the varying demands of their teams and situations.
Situational leadership emphasizes the need for leaders to adjust their style rather than expecting the team to adapt.
As a leader, if you want someone to be a 10, you have to be a flexible leader. Ask, ‘Where are they at?’ and ‘How can I help them get where they want to go?’ They're not going to adapt to you; you have to adapt to them.
This approach requires leaders to be observant, flexible, and responsive to the needs of their team members as well as the situations they face.
Situational leadership helps you adapt your leadership style so you can guide each team member effectively.
The model is made up of four key styles: Directing, Coaching, Supporting, and Delegating. Each style is paired with the level of guidance and support your team needs and the maturity level they have.
The goal? To help your team become more independent, skilled, and confident over time.
Here, the terms D1, D2, D3, and D4 refer to Developmental Levels of employees, which match with the Situational leadership styles (S1, S2, S3, and S4).
This is suitable for team members who are enthusiastic but lack the necessary skills for a task. They need clear instructions and close supervision to build their capabilities.
Example: A new graduate joining a marketing team might need step-by-step guidance on how to conduct market research.
Ideal for individuals who have some competence but are not consistent. They benefit from encouragement and guidance and need to develop more confidence in their skills.
Example: A junior engineer who shows potential but occasionally makes errors may need a mix of direction and motivational support.
This leadership style suits team members who are competent and can handle tasks independently but may require some encouragement to beat self-doubt and boost their confidence and motivation.
Example: A sales representative who consistently meets targets but needs reassurance to take on a challenging client.
Best for highly skilled and motivated team members. They are accountable, capable of working independently, and require minimal supervision.
Example: A senior project manager handling cross-functional projects can make decisions and lead initiatives without needing constant oversight.
In emergencies or high-stake scenarios, a more directive or authoritative approach might be necessary to make quick decisions and maintain control.
Example: During a critical system outage, a team leader might take charge by assigning specific tasks and setting strict timelines.
In day-to-day operations, a more participative or delegating approach can empower team members, foster collaboration, and encourage initiative.
Example: In regular weekly meetings, a manager might use a collaborative style, seeking input from all team members to improve processes.
When launching new projects, a coaching style can be effective to inspire and guide the team, helping them align with the new vision and develop the necessary skills.
Example: Introducing a new software tool might require leaders to provide training and support while encouraging team members to explore its full potential.
Let's dive into some practical examples to see how Situational leadership can work in real-life scenarios.
Imagine you're managing a team responsible for developing a new software product. Initially, you start with the Directing style, giving clear instructions and overseeing each step. As your team becomes more familiar with the project, you shift to Coaching, providing guidance while also encouraging them to think independently. Eventually, you move to Supporting and then Delegating, allowing them to take full ownership of the project. The result? A more skilled, confident, and autonomous team.
Picture this: You're leading a team through various phases of a project. In the early stages, you use the Directing style to ensure everyone in team is aligned and understands their roles and responsibilities. As the project progresses and the team becomes more comfortable, you switch to Coaching and then Supporting. By the final phase, you're in Delegating mode, trusting your team to deliver the project successfully.
A new team member joins with some relevant experience but also gaps in their skills and knowledge. You start with a combination of Directing and Coaching, helping them settle into their role. After a few weeks, they gain confidence and skill. You transition to Supporting, providing occasional guidance. Eventually, you move to Delegating, trusting them to handle their responsibilities independently.
Situational leadership is less about flipping a switch and more about tuning in to your team's needs to help them and your team navigate different situations.
With a little effort, the adaptability you gain from Situational leadership can make you a better leader and, in turn, help your team reach their full potential. It's a small change that can lead to big results for your career and your team.
7 min read
Gavin Brown : Feb 27, 2025 10:19:44 AM
Have you ever wondered why some people seem to just naturally know how to lead and inspire others? It turns out that there are scientific theories...
6 min read
Gavin Brown : Jan 21, 2025 5:37:34 AM
Leadership is not a one-size-fits-all quality.
2 min read
Michelle Bennett : Apr 8, 2022 5:00:00 AM
What’s your leadership style? From new managers to seasoned executives, it is not uncommon for the answer to this question to be along the lines of...
Gavin Brown